The first three times Hector Arvizu was released from prison, it was the same story.
![]() |
|
Parole officer Joe Keevama talks with a parolee's relative to help the family get ready |
It might take a month, and once, it took a year and
a half, but always he went back to using
methamphetamine and wound up back in prison.
But this time, Arvizu, 38, is serving his yearlong
sentence in a special prison yard created to make
inmates more successful when they are released. He
earned his GED, is taking mandatory classes to learn
to make better choices and already is creating a
transition plan for his release in two months.
Arvizu is benefiting from a nationwide push to focus
more efforts on prisoner re-entry to reduce
recidivism and prevent future crimes.
When he walks out of prison this time, Arvizu will
move into a halfway house for three months.
He'll go back to work as a house painter and
continue to attend substance-abuse counseling.
"I feel good about getting out this time," Arvizu
said. "Last time, I really wasn't excited about
getting out. I knew I was going to mess up. This
time, I know it's going to be different. I'm going
to succeed."
Parolee
population
In Arizona and across
the country, a burgeoning number of people are being
released from prison each year, the by-product of a
40-year trend of increased incarceration.
In 2006, one in every 284 Americans was on parole. Nationwide, parole entries have crept up in every year except one since 2000.
In Arizona, the number of felons on parole, called community supervision in this state, has more than doubled in the past 16 years. Arizona inmates typically serve 85 percent of their sentence behind bars and 15 percent on community supervision.
An Arizona Republic analysis of nearly 5,000 convicts on community supervision found they are living in virtually every Valley ZIP code, from the wealthiest in Paradise Valley to the poorest in central Phoenix.
With that come new efforts to help them become productive members of society. In Arizona, money now is being deducted from inmate wages to fund transition programs for certain drug offenders.
Prison officials also are overhauling pre-release preparation and have launched a pilot program to better ease the transition for at least some of those coming out of prison. The programs already are showing promise, with early recidivism rates lower than state and national averages.
"Focusing on the sentence alone does not give our state all of the protection it deserves," said Dora Schriro, director of the Arizona Department of Corrections. "The sentence is a finite period of time, and then it's over. And when it's over, they come home. The question we should ask is: How do we want them? You don't just want them not committing new crimes. You want them civil and productive."
Mounting obstacles
Debbie
Mukamal, director of the Prisoner Re-entry Institute
at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New
York, said inmates typically leave prison with
physical and mental-health issues and
substance-abuse problems that need to be addressed.
They also lack education and job skills. Although
they have served their time, convictions bar felons
from many jobs, from state and federal aid and from
some types of housing.
In Arizona, employers can even ask about arrests
that never led to a conviction, and some may refuse
to hire anyone with a record. Anyone convicted of a
drug felony is barred for life from receiving public
assistance and food stamps. If they can't adjust,
they will go back to their old ways.
"The stakes are high for all of us, even if they're
not coming back directly to our neighborhoods,"
Mukamal said.
As a result, she said, there is a realization that
more resources need to be focused where the risk is
greatest, with newly released inmates.
Across the country, initiatives are under way to
help. Programs range from making sure released
inmates have the basic identification needed to get
a job to building re-entry facilities to providing
tax credits and incentives to businesses that hire
ex-offenders.
Nationally, Congress is debating the Second Chance
Act of 2007, which would allocate $165 million for
re-entry programs. The House passed the act in
November.
"Once the punishment has been complete, you also
have to have some compassion for that person," said
Donna Hamm, executive director of Middle Ground
Prison Reform. "There has to be an opportunity for
redemption, and not just personal redemption but
societal redemption."
Program
reform
Corrections Director Schriro has been working for four years to transform Arizona prisons into a "parallel universe" where inmates engage full time in activities that mirror the outside world. Schriro said the goal is to make inmates successful "because we want the community to be safe."
Re-entry preparation and support is part of that, and it starts with education, vocational training and substance-abuse counseling the moment a person is incarcerated.
Three initiatives show early signs of success:
• Level 1 beds for minimum-security inmates within two years of release have been opened at the Perryville, Tucson and Douglas prisons. Inmates who have earned their GEDs and completed work-based education and job training work full time during the days, then spend their evenings planning their transitions back to the community and taking classes on topics such as cultural diversity, parenting skills and conflict resolution.
During fiscal 2006 and 2007, 1,588 men and women completed the program. Only 22, about 1.4 percent, have returned to prison with new felony charges.
That is a dramatic decrease from the state's overall recidivism rate: 16.2 percent of inmates return to custody with a new felony conviction within two years of release. By the third year, the recidivism rate is nearly one in four. Nationwide, the recidivism rate for parolees was 16 percent in 2006.
• The Fast Track program, begun in September 2006, is geared toward minimum-custody inmates sentenced to fewer than six months in prison. The Fast Track units at Perryville and Florence immediately focus on discharge planning and try to instill "life-coping, get-along skills."
There also is a push to get a GED.
Arvizu, who is on his fourth stint in prison, said the small yard, individual attention from counselors and high expectations have made a difference.
"It makes you want to succeed and not do drugs," Arvizu said. "They really opened my eyes to see what I have out there and what I'm losing out there. When you come here, you lose everything. Hopefully, this time I'll make wiser choices."
About 1,240 inmates completed the Fast Track program in the first 13 months. Eighteen percent have returned to custody. Only 35 of those, or 3 percent, had new charges; the other 189 were returned for technical violations of parole.
Schriro said that, with four out of every 10 inmates serving six months or less, she plans to expand the program in January to inmates at higher custody levels.
"It's way too early to declare victory, but it's a promising indicator about our underlying premise," Schriro said. "When you press the population to make better decisions and you give them the education and the job skills, guess what happens? They succeed."
• The Legacy Program, which began July 1, is a more hands-on, collaborative approach to stabilizing parolees in ZIP codes that bear a disproportionate concentration of returning offenders. Parole officers are partnering with other state agencies to provide easier access to resources, housing and health care. The pilot program, launched in south Phoenix's 85041 ZIP code, will begin expanding in January. Eventually, it will encompass three south Phoenix ZIP codes, two in Tucson and one in Yuma.
Early
results
It's too
early to see if the approach will help, but 57
inmates already have started with the pilot program.
Four successfully completed community supervision,
and four have had their parole revoked. Only one,
though, involved committing a new felony: possession
of burglary tools.
In one case, where a woman struggling with sobriety
previously would have seen parole revoked, parole
officers got her into a halfway house, lined up
substance-abuse counseling and provided vouchers for
clothing and toiletries.
"It's easy for us as parole officers to lock
somebody up if they don't comply," said Jerry
Eitniear, a parole manager. "But the community isn't
served really by incarcerating this individual. If
you start taking care of the problem now, and you
start changing her way, then she'll become
successful. We want them to have the skills and the
ability to remain clean and sober and stay in
society and be successful."
A second
chance
Ellen
Williams, 48, didn't participate in any of Schriro's
new programs before getting out of prison in 2003,
but Williams is a testament to the success inmates
can experience with a little help.
Williams served 3½ years in prison after police
raided her Peoria home in 2000 and found a
half-million-dollar meth lab. She sobered up before
she went to prison and spent her time behind bars
working, taking classes and planning for her
release.
She also enrolled in an outreach program called
Women Living Free, which works with women a year
before their release and then provides transitional
housing, clothing and support services for two
years.
When she was released, Williams moved onto the
Phoenix campus of Homeward Bound. She got a job and
eventually became a carpenter.
"Luckily, I went to prison because it snapped me out
of everything," Williams said. "It was a gift."
These days, she lives in a rent-capped Homeward
Bound house in Scottsdale. She earns nearly $21 an
hour and has health insurance. On Sundays, she sells
worms at Bartlett Lake.
"I work real hard every day," Williams said.
She has rebuilt her relationship with her daughter
and dreams of owning acreage and riding horses
competitively as a jockey. She volunteers as a
mentor for other women coming out of prison.
In August, Williams graduated from Phoenix College
with a degree in massage therapy, although she can't
get her license until she completes probation. She
hopes to do that in time to vote in next year's
election.
"I'm thankful that I've been given a chance, but
I've also applied myself," Williams said.
"I knew I was doing the wrong thing. I'm not going
to ever do that again. I'm in such a nice place
now."

